中国农业大学经济管理学院;山西财经大学国际贸易学院;
联合国可持续发展目标(SDGs)框架下,环境、社会和治理(ESG)为贸易结构转型升级提供了新契机。文章基于2007—2016年中国上市公司与海关匹配数据,从环境与经济可持续双重视角切入,探讨企业实施ESG策略对其出口产品结构升级的影响。研究结果表明:实施ESG策略整体上能够促进出口产品结构向绿色化和高级化升级,这一积极作用主要通过绿色技术创新机制实现;由于ESG具有显著的外溢性,其影响还会沿着供应链向上下游延伸,并通过加强供应商绿色管理以及促进声誉溢价进一步强化绿色创新机制;从动态来看,ESG策略下企业出口产品结构升级主要在扩展边际通过“扩绿扩高”和“优胜劣汰”实现,即扩展绿色产品和高技术产品,淘汰非绿色产品和低技术产品;此外,实施ESG策略对出口产品结构升级的积极作用并非绝对,对于从事加工贸易、采取成本竞争型策略以及高污染行业的传统企业而言,ESG存在“惩罚机制”,尽管ESG策略下的环境治理促进了出口产品结构绿色化,但环境投资会对创新性投资产生“挤出效应”,导致出口产品结构难以向高级化转型,使得这类企业面临减排与发展的矛盾关系。在“双碳”目标和高质量发展背景下,文章为构建绿色、高效的贸易发展体系提供了重要决策参考。
1,526 | 0 | 48 |
下载次数 | 被引频次 | 阅读次数 |
[1] Acemoglu D,Johnson S,Robinson J A.The colonial origins of comparative development:An empirical investigation[J].The American Economic Review,2001,91(5):1369-1401.
[2] Brandi C,Schwab C,Berger A,et al.Do environmental provisions in trade agreements make exports from developing countries greener?[J].World Development,2020,129:104899.
[3] Brandt L,Biesebroeck J V,WANG L,et al.WTO accession and performance of Chinese manufacturing firms[J].American Economic Review,2017,107 (9):2784-2820.
[4] Centobelli P,Cerchione R,Esposito E,et al.Determinants of the transition towards circular economy in SMEs:A sustainable supply chain management perspective[J].International Journal of Production Economics,2021,242:108297.
[5] CHANG X,FU K,Low A,et al.Non-executive employee stock options and corporate innovation[J].Journal of Financial Economics,2015,115(1):168-188.
[6] CHEN Y S.The drivers of green brand equity:Green brand image,green satisfaction,and green trust[J].Journal of Business Ethics,2010,93:307-319.
[7] Chintrakarn P.Environmental regulation and U.S.states′ technical inefficiency[J].Economics Letters,2008,100(3):363-365.
[8] Cowan K,Guzman F.How CSR reputation,sustainability signals,and country-of-origin sustainability reputation contribute to corporate brand performance:An exploratory study[J].Journal of Business Research,2020,117:683-693.
[9] Dasgupta K,Mondria J.Quality uncertainty and intermediation in international trade[J].European Economic Review,2018,104:68-91.
[10] Dekhili S,Achabou M A.Price fairness in the case of green products:Enterprises′ policies and consumers′ perceptions[J].Business Strategy and the Environment,2013,22:547-560.
[11] Duque-Grisales E,Aguilera-Caracuel J.Environmental,social and governance (ESG) scores and financial performance of multilatinas:Moderating effects of geographic international diversification and financial slack[J].Journal of Business Ethics,2021,168:315-334.
[12] Elrod A A,Malik A S.The effect of environmental regulation on plant-level product mix:A study of EPA′s Cluster Rule[J].Journal of Environmental Economics and Management,2017,83:164-184.
[13] Fiorillo P,Meles A,Pellegrino L R,et al.Geopolitical risk and stock price crash risk:The mitigating role of ESG performance[J].International Review of Financial Analysis,2024,91:102958.
[14] Flammer C,Bansal P.Does a long-term orientation create value?Evidence from a regression discontinuity[J].Strategic Management Journal,2017,38:1827-1847.
[15] Gjergji R,Vena L,Sciascia S,et al.The effects of environmental,social and governance disclosure on the cost of capital in small and medium enterprises:The role of family business status[J].Business Strategy and the Environment,2021,30:683-693.
[16] Habermann F,Fischer F B.Corporate social performance and the likelihood of bankruptcy:Evidence from a period of economic upswing[J].Journal of Business Ethics,2023,182:243-259.
[17] Hausmann R,Hidalgo C A.The network structure of economic output [J].Journal of Economic Growth,2011,16 (4):309-342.
[18] HE J J,HUANG J,ZHAO S.Internalizing governance externalities:The role of institutional cross-ownership[J].Journal of Financial Economics,2019,134(2):400-418.
[19] HE J J,TIAN X.The dark side of analyst coverage:The case of innovation[J].Journal of Financial Economics,2013,109(3):856-878.
[20] HUANG X,HU Z,LIU C,et al.The relationships between regulatory and customer pressure,green organizational responses,and green innovation performance[J].Journal of Cleaner Production,2016,112:3423-3433.
[21] Hur W M,Kim H,Woo J.How CSR leads to corporate brand equity:Mediating mechanisms of corporate brand credibility and reputation[J].Journal of Business Ethics,2014,125:75-86.
[22] Khandelwal A K,Schott P K,WEI S J.Trade liberalization and embedded institutional reform:Evidence from Chinese exporters[J].American Economic Review,2013,103(6):2169-2195.
[23] Kim J W,Park C K.Can ESG performance mitigate information asymmetry?Moderating effect of assurance services[J].Applied Economics,2022,55(26):2993-3007.
[24] KUANG X,LUO C.Corporate ESG performance and litigation risk-based on ESG lawsuits of listed firms in China[J].Applied Economics Letters,2024:1-6.
[25] Lall S.The technological structure and performance of developing country manufactured exports,1985-1998 [J].Oxford Development Studies,2000,28(3):337-369.
[26] LI Q.The effect of ESG performance on enterprises′ internationalization:From the perspective of cooperative research and development[J].Applied Economics Letters,2024:1-5.
[27] LUO L,TANG Q.The real effects of ESG reporting and GRI standards on carbon mitigation:International evidence[J].Business Strategy and the Environment,2022,32(6):2985-3000.
[28] Melitz M J.The impact of trade on industry reallocations and aggregate industry productivity[J].Econometrica,2003,71:1695-1725.
[29] Pástor L,Stambaugh R F,Taylor L A.Sustainable investing in equilibrium[J].Journal of Financial Economics,2021,142(2):550-571.
[30] Porter M E.Competitive strategy:Techniques for analyzing industries and competitors[D].New York:Free Press,1980.
[31] Porter M E.American′s green strategy[J].Scientific American,1991,264(4):168.
[32] Pucker K P,King A.ESG investing isn′t designed to save the planet[R].Harvard Business Review,2022,August 01.
[33] Riedl A,Smeets P.Why do investors hold socially responsible mutual funds?[J] The Journal of Finance,2017,72:2505-2550.
[34] Rojo-Suárez J,Alonso-Conde A B.Short-run and long-run effects of ESG policies on value creation and the cost of equity of firms[J].Economic Analysis and Policy,2023,77:599-616.
[35] Schott P K.One size fits all?Heckscher-Ohlin specialization in global production[J].American Economic Review,2003,93(3):686-708.
[36] Sauvage J.The stringency of environmental regulations and trade in environmental goods[R].OECD Trade and Environment Working Papers,2014.
[37] WANG Y,XIONG S,MA X.Carbon inequality in global trade:Evidence from the mismatch between embodied carbon emissions and value-added[J].Ecological Economics,2022,195:107398.
[38] WEI X,WEI Q,YANG L.Induced green innovation of suppliers:The "green power" from major customers[J].Energy Economics,2023,124:106775.
[39] YU C,WU X,ZHANG D,et al.Demand for green finance:Resolving financing constraints on green innovation in China[J].Energy Policy,2021,153:112255.
[40] YU X,CHEN Y.Does ESG advantage promote total factor productivity (TFP) Empirical evidence from China′s listed enterprises[J].Applied Economics,2024:1-17.
[41] ZHANG Z,HOU Y,LI Z,et al.From symbolic to substantive green innovation:How does ESG ratings optimize corporate green innovation structure[J].Finance Research Letters,2024,63:105401.
[42] ZHAO P,YAO X,SHEN R.Capital market internationalization and firms′ ESG performance:Evidence from the inclusion of China A-shares in the MSCI Emerging Market Index[J].Energy Economics,2024,133:107415.
[43] 安占然,王帅,朱廷珺.ESG表现是否促进了企业出口?——来自中国上市公司的微观证据[J].南方经济,2024(6):138-158.
[44] 陈芳,吴春玮,冯权伟.ESG表现对企业出口影响研究[J].亚太经济,2023(6):103-115.
[45] 陈诗一,吴绪成,王川杰.税收优惠、人力资本结构调整与高新技术企业创新[J].世界经济文汇,2023(5):1-16.
[46] 戴魁早,黄姿,王思曼.创新型城市政策、要素市场一体化与出口技术复杂度[J].国际贸易问题,2023(12):114-131.
[47] 胡洁,于宪荣,韩一鸣.ESG评级能否促进企业绿色转型?——基于多时点双重差分法的验证[J].数量经济技术经济研究,2023,40(7):90-111.
[48] 江艇.因果推断经验研究中的中介效应与调节效应[J].中国工业经济,2022(5):100-120.
[49] 金祥义,戴金平.有效信息披露与企业出口表现[J].世界经济,2019,42(5):99-122.
[50] 黎峰.全球价值链下的出口产品结构与贸易收益——基于增加值视角[J].世界经济研究,2016(3):86-96;135-136.
[51] 李江,祝树金,阳立高.环境信息公开、质量调整与多产品企业出口[J].产业经济研究,2024(3):128-142.
[52] 廖秋娴,李荣林,熊治.区域市场一体化与企业出口质量:基于撤县设区的视角[J].国际贸易问题,2024(1):50-67.
[53] 施炳展.中国出口结构在优化吗——基于产品内分类的视角[J].财经科学,2010(5):77-84.
[54] 苏莉,魏浩.ESG表现对中国企业海外收益影响的机制与效应研究[J].世界经济研究,2024(5):92-108;136.
[55] 王俊,陈丽娴,梁洋华.FTA环境条款是否会推动中国出口产品“清洁化”?[J].世界经济研究,2021(3):49-66;135.
[56] 王翌秋,谢萌,郭冲.企业ESG表现影响银行信贷决策吗——基于中国A股上市公司的经验证据[J].金融经济学研究,2023,38(5):97-114.
[57] 魏浩.中国出口商品结构变化的重新测算[J].国际贸易问题,2015(4):16-26.
[58] 魏浩,张宇鹏.融资约束与中国企业出口产品结构调整[J].世界经济,2020,43(6):146-170.
[59] 谢红军,吕雪.负责任的国际投资:ESG与中国OFDI[J].经济研究,2022,57(3):83-99.
[60] 严兵,程敏,王乃合.ESG绿色溢出、供应链传导与企业绿色创新[J].经济研究,2024,59(7):72-91.
[61] 杨冕,王恩泽,叶初升.环境管理体系认证与中国制造业企业出口“增量提质”[J].中国工业经济,2022(6):155-173.
[62] 张小蒂,李晓钟.我国出口商品结构变化的实证分析[J].数量经济技术经济研究,2002(8):109-112.
[63] 周沂,郭琪,邹冬寒.环境规制与企业产品结构优化策略——来自多产品出口企业的经验证据[J].中国工业经济,2022(6):117-135.
① 《国家发展改革委关于印发<节能低碳技术推广管理暂行办法>的通知》中的“二氧化碳减排量估算方法及参数选择”中公布了各种能源的排放系数,详见https://www.ndrc.gov.cn/xxgk/zcfb/tz/201401/t20140110_964014.html。
② 具体测算公式为:■。其中,pfkt表示企业f在t年k产品的出口价格,∑n∈Ni μnktpnkt为所有企业k产品出口价格的加权均值,μnkt为n企业t年k产品出口额占k产品总出口额的比重,pnkt为n企业t年k产品的出口价格,Ni表示出口企业组合,μkt表示企业t年k产品出口额占该企业总出口的比重,Ki表示出口产品组合。
(1)笔者依据CEPII数据进行测算而得,具体测算方法见本文变量选取部分。
(1)数据来源:2024年11月7日,国务院国资委发布的《中央企业上市公司ESG蓝皮书》。
(1)2010年低碳城市试点名单:广东、辽宁、湖北、陕西、云南五省;天津、重庆、深圳、厦门、杭州、南昌、贵阳、保定八市。
(1)采用LP方法测算。
(2)限于篇幅,估计结果未予给出,留存备索。
(1)高污染行业包括:食品制造业(C14),石油加工、炼焦及核燃料加工业(C25),化学原料及化学制品制造业(C26),黑色金属冶炼及压延加工业(C32),有色金属冶炼及压延加工业(C33),农副食品加工业(C13),纺织业(C17),皮革、毛皮、羽毛(绒)及其制品业(C19),造纸及纸制品业(C22),非金属矿物制品业(C31),电力、热力的生产和供应业(D44),煤炭开采和洗选业(B06),黑色金属矿采选业(B08),有色金属矿采选业(B09),非金属矿采选业(B10),医药制造业(C27),化学纤维制造业(C28),石油和天然气开采业(B07),饮料制造业(C15),木材加工及木竹藤棕草制品业(C20),通用设备、计算机及其他电子设备制造业(C40),水的生产和供应业(D46),金属制品业(C34),通用设备制造业(C35),专用设备制造业(C36),交通运输设备制造业(C37)。其余行业为中低污染行业。
基本信息:
DOI:10.13516/j.cnki.wes.2025.04.006
中图分类号:X322;F752.62;F832.51
引用信息:
[1]魏萍,刘宏曼,许朝凯.ESG与出口产品结构升级:基于环境和经济可持续视角[J].世界经济研究,2025,No.374(04):40-57+134-135.DOI:10.13516/j.cnki.wes.2025.04.006.
基金信息:
教育部人文社会科学基金项目“数字技术赋能中国农食系统减碳增效的影响机制及路径研究”(项目编号:23YJA790049); 中国高等教育学会2023年度高等教育科学研究规划课题“中美竞争背景下中国-东盟‘一带一路’合作研究”(项目编号:23BR0205)的阶段性成果